Butter Lane Classic Mix

Butter Lane Gift Box

Fruit Lover

Chocolate Lovers

Specialty Cupcakes Dozen

Valentine’s Specialty Dozen “Pre-order Now”

Base: Vanilla (click to pick icing)

Base: Chocolate (click to pick icing)

Base: Banana (click to pick icing)

Two Dozen Minis

Icing Shot Assortment (6 boxes) 

  • Select options

    Sea Salt chocolate cake “48 HR Notice & Pick up only”

    $60.00 – $90.00
  • Select options

    Butterlane Birthday cake “48 HR Notice & Pick up only”

    $70.00 – $100.00
  • Select options

    Fudge brownie cake “48 HR Notice & Pick up only”

    $70.00 – $100.00
  • Select options

    Build your own Cake”48hrs Notice and Pick Up only”

    $60.00 – $160.00
  • Select options

    Valentine’s day two layers cake “48hrs Notice and Pick Up only”

    $45.00 – $60.00
  • Add to cart

    Valentines cookie package (Cupcake & Heart) “Pre-order only, 48hrs notice”

    $18.00
  • Add to cart

    Valentines cookie package (Mike & cookie) “Pre-order only, 48hrs notice”

    $18.00
  • Add to cart

    Valentines cookie package (Pizza Lovers Theme) “Pre-order only, 48hrs notice”

    $18.00
  • Add to cart

    Valentines cookie package (Stay away from me) “Pre-order only, 48hrs notice”

    $18.00
  • Add to cart

    Chocolate chips cookie (2 cookies in each pack)

    $3.00
  • Add to cart

    Fudge Brownies

    $3.00
  • Add to cart

    Ginger snap (2 cookies in each pack)

    $3.00
  • Add to cart

    Shortbread (2 cookies in each pack)

    $3.00

Call (212)677-2880 to ask about our specialty cookies